Independent daily Newspaper

 Home

 Old Archive RSS Feed    Advertise

About

Music 

 Syria: Whatever happened to balanced reporting?

 Opinion — Analysis  
  The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of the author

 


Syria: Whatever happened to balanced reporting?  2.1.2013 
By Sheila Mosley
Special to Ekurd.net







 
Salih Muslim Muhammed, the leader of the biggest Kurdish party in Syria, the Democratic Union Party [PYD], and Vice-President of the National Coordination. Photo: Archive.   See Related Articles 
January 2, 2013

How many reports have we seen telling us that Kurds in Syria are working for al-Assad, that the Kurdish PKK (from Turkey) is behind the actions of Kurdish Democratic Union Party – PYD, that PYD runs the Kurdish area, and that Kurds are divided? There are many.

In contrast, where are the articles that positively report the unity of the Kurdish political parties and the creation of a safe area within the Kurdish region in the North-East where those who come without weapons are welcomed and cared for? Where are the articles that give voice to those working for a solution based on dialogue and non-violence? There are just a few.

The media in the main is allowing itself to be used to discredit those who do not fight with FSA or call for armed resistance, and it is not offering balanced reporting. This is at best naive and at worst vindictive and malicious, and serves the aims of those who have their own agendas for trying to destroy the fragile unity between the Kurdish parties, and to silence the voice of non-violent action and diplomacy. It is a dangerous strategy because it fuels sectarianism and increases the vulnerability of Kurds and others living in the Kurdish area. By way of example, see reports on 28/29 Dec 2012 in Deutsche Welle [1], and Rudaw [2].

Where is it reported that Salih Muslim is working tirelessly to find a solution that will secure basic rights for Kurds in Syria but which will benefit all those living in the Kurdish area within Syria, and for Syria as a country? He is a leader within PYD, also a member of the Kurdish Supreme Council - the collaboration between the PYD and the Kurdish National Council which has brought stability to the Kurdish area, and he is a PYD representative on the National Coordination Body for Democratic Change in Syria - NCB. In response to comments frequently made in the press he has made it clear that PYD is not a part of PKK, and that he is committed to working for a non-violent solution – self-defence aside [3], [4] but this is repeatedly and deliberately being ignored to undermine his credibility as a peacemaker, and as a representative of a sizeable proportion of the Kurdish population in Syria.

Kurds are accused of sitting on the fence. Salih Muslim explains that Kurds have so often been used to fight other people’s battles, but this time they have not come out to fight for either the regime which has brutally oppressed them over the years [5],
www.ekurd.net or the Turkey-backed ‘FSA’ [6] because they cannot see a positive future with either, especially as Turkey continues to deny basic democratic rights to its own Kurdish population, and so they take care of the interests of those living in their area. This is not often reported, and instead Kurds are criticised for not joining FSA and the armed struggle.

When comments from Haytham Manna of National Coordination Body for Democratic Change in Syria - NCB are included in a report he is derided to minimise the impact of his stance as the advocate a of non-violent solution. Where are his arguments against the use of violence explained, and the reasoning behind the NCB’s three ‘no’s: no to violence, sectarianism and foreign military intervention [7]? Rarely.

The international community has responsibility for this conflict that has become a blood bath for hundreds of people in Syria every week. The UN is frequently blamed, but it will continue to be disabled by the proxy wars that are being acted out using the lives of the Syrian people: America and Russia continue their economic and geo-political cold war; Iran and Saudi Arabia lock horns about power and control within Sunni and Shia Islam; and Turkey is yet to find an acceptable way to live with its own Kurdish population.

Those who control the media need to take seriously their responsibilities and duty of care for Syrians who are suffering every day. This is a crucial time for balanced reporting and respect for those whose voices have been stifled by the baying for weapons.

1 Naomi Conrad: Kurds caught up in midst of Syrian conflict 29.12.2012 http://www.dw.de/kurds-caught-up-in-midst-of-syrian-conflict/a-16484448
2 Rudaw: Kurdish Opposition Groups Question Syrian Delegation’s Meeting With Maliki 29.12.2012 http://www.rudaw.net/english/news/syria/5601.html
3 Peace in Kurdistan/SKS: Monday 3 December 2012 http://supportkurds.org/news/monday-3-december-2012
4 SKS: Kurds need freedom and democracy: PYD leader http://supportkurds.org/news/kurds-need-freedom-and-democracy-pyd-leader
5 SKS: Brief Overview http://supportkurds.org/reports/brief-overview
6 Tisdall, S., 2012 Iran and Turkey's meeting reveals new approach to Syria The Guardian
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/oct/25/iran-turkey-new-approach-syria
7 SKS: Haytham Manna: Violence and Democratic Perspectives in Syria 23 October 2012
http://supportkurds.org/reports/haytham-manna-violence-and-democratic-perspectives-in-syria

 

Sheila Mosley. Co-Chair: International Support Kurds in Syria Association – SKS, 1 January 2013 - Ekurd.net

Copyright © 2013 Ekurd.net

 

Top

  The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of the author

 
 

Copyright © 1998-2023 Kurd Net® . All rights reserved. Ekurd.net
All documents and images on this website are copyrighted and may not be used without the express
permission of the copyright holder.