|
In Syria, a Kurdish wildcard no one wants
to play
6.5.2012
By Piotr Zalewski - The National UAE |
|
|
|
|

Kurdish protesters at a meeting of the Democratic
Society Party in Nusaybin. Photo: Jean-Philippe
Ksiazek/AFP
•
See Related Links
May 6, 2012
The drive through town had become something of
an obstacle course. On some streets, young boys,
stones in hand, squared off against policemen, each
group waiting for the other to make the first move.
In other parts of the city, chunks of broken
pavement, remnants of recent clashes, rendered any
attempt at passage impossible. It was the evening of
March 20 and Nusaybin - a town in Turkey's
Kurdish-dominated south-east - was still on edge.
Earlier in the day, riot police had fired tear gas
and water cannons on men and women marching back
from a rally to celebrate Newroz, the Kurdish New
Year. Similar scenes were to play out across the
region throughout the week, after Turkish
authorities decided to ban Newroz celebrations held
on any day other than March 21.
At the offices of Mar-Has, the final stop on our
ride through Nusaybin, the focus - rather than on
the festering conflict between Turkey and its Kurds
- was on events in Syria. Nusaybin lies within
earshot of the border and Mar-Has, an NGO, helps
people fleeing the country find their footing in
Turkey, says Mir Mehmet, one of the group's members.
"We provide them with food, with blankets, and we
help find homes for them," he says.
Syria is said to be home to at least two million
Kurds, many of them descended from families who fled
Turkey after a series of bloodily suppressed Kurdish
rebellions in the 1920s and 1930s. The government in
Damascus having denied these Kurds citizenship,
hundreds of thousands were left in limbo, unable to
claim basic rights in Syria and - lacking national
identity papers - unable to travel abroad.
That impasse was finally broken in April 2011 when
Syrian president Bashar Al Assad, doing his best to
appease the Kurdish minority and ensure that it
remain on the sidelines of the anti-government
revolution raging across Syria, promised to grant
citizenship to 300,000 stateless Kurds. For those
who hoped to take advantage of the measure to travel
to Nusaybin, if only to call on relatives, the
opportunity to do so proved short-lived. At the
beginning of 2012, Al Assad's regime decided to
close the border crossing between Nusaybin and its
neighbouring sister city, Qamishli. Syrian Kurds
attempting to enter Nusaybin now have to do so
illegally, with the help of a smuggler, or via the
closest border crossing still open, at Kilis, almost
500 kilometres away.
Although there may be as many as several hundred
Syrians currently living in Nusaybin, few were
willing to be interviewed, citing security concerns.
Of those who agreed to speak, Munteser Sino claimed
that during his first attempt to sneak across the
border he was detained by Turkish border guards and
sent back to Syria.
To date, Turkish authorities have received and
accommodated well over 25,000 Syrian refugees,
nearly all of them arriving in Hatay, a southern
province of Turkey. The government in Ankara remains
wary of new arrivals from Kurdish-populated
northeastern Syria, however.
Some of these, Turkish officials fear, may be
infiltrators from the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK),
a militant group that has waged war against the
Turkish army since 1984. (Some 40,000 people,
including militants, soldiers and civilians, have
died since the beginning of the conflict. Turkey,
the United States and the European Union all list
the PKK as a terrorist organisation. Many of
Turkey's 12-15 million Kurds would disagree. To
them, the group remains a symbol of resistance
against a Turkish state that is yet to meet the
Kurds' demands for cultural rights and some measure
of political autonomy.)
Sino had been involved in the anti-Al Assad
revolution from the start, he says. Among other
things, he had helped diffuse videos of protests in
Qamishli. Apprehended by Syrian agents during a trip
to Lebanon, he was brought to Damascus and tortured
for three consecutive days, he recalls.
When Syrian military intelligence tried to recruit
him to spy on fellow opposition members, he refused.
Once released, Sino attempted to flee Syria.
Apprehended the first time around, he tried once
again and succeeded. Like many Kurds on the Syrian
side of the border, Sino has family members in
Nusaybin, he says. "I prefer to stay with them
rather than in the refugee camps in Hatay."
Ibrahim, another Syrian activist based in Nusaybin,
fled Qamishli in February. Back in Syria, he had
been arrested twice, he says - once on account of
his political activities, and once on account of his
brother's. The day we met, he had received a phone
call from his sister in Syria. Intelligence agents
had asked about his whereabouts, she told him. The
family had feigned ignorance.
Sitting in a small park overlooking the border area,
Ibrahim points to several watchtowers, a field
tilled by Syrian farmers, and to rows of barbed
wire. This, he says, is where he snuck across the
border and into Turkey. He comes here often, he
says. "But no, not out of nostalgia," he protests,
laughing, "but because it's one of the few places in
Nusaybin where I can get coverage on my mobile
phone, which is Syrian."
Although protests have regularly taken place in
Kurdish towns across Syria since the spring of 2011,
many experts suggest that the Syrian Kurds are yet
to throw in their lot with the anti-Assad
revolution. Qamishli-based activists insist the
opposite, however, claiming that they have taken to
the streets just as often as fellow Arab protesters.
If Qamishli has not seen the kind of violence
witnessed elsewhere in Syria, they say, it is
because the regime has shrewdly decided to spare the
Kurds the kind of indiscriminate force meted out to
protesters in Homs, Hama or Idlib.
"They think that if they attack us hard, they will
lose Damascus and Aleppo," says Alan Hassaf, a
student activist. Both cities, he explains, are home
to hundreds of thousands of Kurds.
Even those Syrian Kurds who've decided to close
ranks with Arab protesters across the country
acknowledge that doing so has taken a leap of faith.
As
they and others recall, back in 2004 when
anti-government riots broke out in Qamishli few if
any Arabs came to the Kurds' aid. Even after Al
Assad's security forces killed dozens of protesters,
sympathy for the Kurds was scarce. "Because of
government propaganda, people thought of us as
terrorists, as separatists," Ibrahim told me.
A number of local Arab tribes actually abetted the
government crackdown. (Some of the tribes in
question had been relocated to areas around Qamishli
in the 1960s in order to dilute the Kurdish
presence. Many remain loyal to the regime to this
day.) The kind of enmity that developed between
Kurds and Arabs over the decades hasn't been easy to
overcome, says Seda Altug, a Turkish researcher. "It
wasn't easy for the Kurds to pick up and join the
revolution right away," she explains.
If the trauma of 2004 has receded, then a more
tangible force appears to be holding back the Kurds.
According to numerous accounts, the PKK and its
Syrian offshoot, the Democratic Union Party (PYD) -
acknowledged as the most powerful among Syria's many
Kurdish groups - have acted as a brake on
anti-regime activities among the Kurds. At best, the
PKK is playing for time, hoping to jump on the
revolutionary bandwagon only once the regime's
downfall is all but assured. At worst, it is
colluding with Assad to contain protests among the
Kurds.
The idea of co-operating with the regime is not
alien to the PKK. Throughout the 1980s and 1990s, Al
Assad's father, former Syrian president Hafez Al
Assad, provided the Kurdish rebels with access to
training camps and allowed Abdullah Ocalan,www.ekurd.net
the PKK's leader, to set up shop in Damascus. The
honeymoon ended in 1998 when Turkey, threatening
force, strong-armed Damascus into expelling Ocalan.
He was later captured and sentenced to death by a
Turkish court. After Turkey abolished capital
punishment, the sentence was commuted to life
imprisonment.
In the 2000s, as Turkey and Syria began to enjoy
warmer ties, Assad cracked down against the PKK,
jailing many of its members and forcing others to
flee abroad. After anti-regime protests broke out
across Syria in 2011, however, the tide changed yet
again. For a beleaguered Damascus government, the
PKK and its political allies acquired renewed
strategic value - both as an extra deterrent against
Turkish intervention and as a means of preventing
the Syrian Kurds from joining the revolution en
masse.
According to several recent reports on the subject,
over the past year the PKK has used intimidation and
force to silence Kurdish anti-regime activists in
Syria.
A Kurdish politician, speaking on condition of
anonymity, recalled that members of the group had
tried to sabotage several anti-regime protests in
Qamishli in the spring of 2011.
At one of these, PKK supporters arrived with banners
featuring pictures of Abdullah Ocalan. "They wanted
to send a message to Turkey and to Syria. They
wanted to show that the Kurds of Syria were under
their control and they wanted to hide the purpose of
the demonstrations," the politician said. When he
asked the PKK members to take down the banners -
"our purpose is not to support Ocalan but to oppose
the Syrian regime," he explained - they threatened
him with death. "Later, they told me, 'If you do
this again, we will kill you. We will kill anyone
who does this. We paid with our blood for this
banner, for this flag.'"
A September 2011 ceasefire between the PJAK (the
PKK's Iranian branch) and the government in Tehran,
the politician added, is clear evidence "that the
PKK, Syria, and Iran have reached an agreement."
There are signs that the PKK and the PYD may be
recalibrating its alliances, however. Although the
PYD had initially been more concerned with its own
interests than with the Syrian regime's overthrow,
says Alan Hassaf, the group has now changed course,
siding more openly with the Kurdish protesters. In
an interview with Kurdwatch, a German-based website,
another Qamishli-based activist reported that the
group "was trying to show the people that it
represents the interests of the Kurds." "Whether we
want it or not, the PYD is currently the strongest
force in Qamishli," he added. "Without the PYD
nothing works."
With Syrian nationals forming anywhere from 10 to 30
per cent of the PKK's membership, parts of the group
may also be coming under pressure to ditch the
alliance with Damascus.
"Some PKK fighters are not satisfied with the
connection with the regime," says Sertac Bucak, a
retired Kurdish politician from Turkey. "But the PKK
is highly centralised. They will do what the
leadership tells them to do - unless they decide to
revolt, which is impossible to foresee for the time
being."
According to Emrullah Uslu, a Turkish analyst, the
PKK and its supporters in Syria may simply be
holding out for a deal with a weakened regime or a
post-Assad government.
As Uslu recently wrote in a commentary for the
Washington-based Jamestown Foundation, "It appears
that the PKK's strategy toward Syria does not call
for fighting beside the Assad regime until the very
end. Rather, it has used the situation to its own
advantage to open new avenues for itself and
strengthen its position within Syria in order to be
ready for further confrontations if the Assad regime
falls."

Men brandish torches and Kurdish flags as they
celebrate Newroz, the Kurdish New Year, in Akra in
Iraqi Kurdistan. Photo: Safin Hamed/AFP
•
See Related Links
Whichever way the PKK may currently be leaning,
the group has made it clear that it will oppose any
outside intervention in Syria, particularly by
Turkey. "If the Turkish state intervenes against our
people in [Syria]," PKK commander Murat Karayilan
told the Europe-based Firat news agency in late
March, "all of Kurdistan will turn into a war zone."
Yet the PKK is far from being the only actor
interested in keeping the Syrian Kurds in check. The
anti-Assad opposition, for one, appears haunted by
what it sees as the looming spectre of Kurdish
separatism.
During a key March 27 meeting in Istanbul, leaders
of the Syrian National Council - the main opposition
platform - preferred to see the Kurds walk out in
protest rather than accept their request for
autonomy in a post-Assad constitution. (The two
sides reconciled a week later after the SNC inserted
a reference to "Kurdish identity" in its "National
Covenant for a New Syria.") While many Syrian
Kurdish activists have pointed to old-school Arab
nationalism as the main culprit, others have placed
part of the blame for the SNC's intransigence at the
door of the Turkish government. Ankara, the SNC's
main backer, is doing its best to prevent the Kurds
from becoming key players in a post-Assad Syria,
they argue. As a member of the Kurdish Democratic
Party in Syria complained in an interview with Rudaw,
a Kurdish newspaper, "the Turkish government will
never allow Kurds to be recognised in Syria's new
constitution."
Such fears are not without basis. Turkey, having
emerged as one of the key supporters of regime
change in Syria, now finds itself in a pickle. On
the one hand, it knows that the Kurds, if rallied,
could potentially tip the balance of the anti-Assad
rebellion. On the other, it worries that a united
Kurdish front could quickly pave the way for another
autonomous Kurdish region - in addition to the one
in northern Iraq - on Turkey's southern border.
This, Turkish officials assume, would further
encourage calls for Kurdish autonomy at home.
Predictably, mistrust towards Turkey's intentions in
Syria also runs high among the country's own Kurdish
minority. "To be against Assad is the duty of anyone
who calls himself a democrat," Ahmet Turk, a former
leader of the pro-Kurdish Peace and Democracy Party
(BDP), told me aboard a March 18 flight to
Diyarbakir. "But if Turkey wants to determine the
future of Syria without accepting the rights and the
existence of the Kurds there, and to try to avoid
giving them political status, that would be the same
kind of unjust, tyrannical policy as Assad's." (Two
days after our interview, the 70-year-old Mr Turk
was rushed to a hospital after being punched in the
face by a Turkish policeman during a Newroz
demonstration.)
Overall, the Turkish Kurds' response to the events
in Syria has been relatively muted, according to
observers. Suspicion of Turkish motives is one
reason. The PKK factor is another. Whatever their
personal sympathies, says Bucak, Turkish Kurds and
their political representatives may be wary of
crossing the PKK when it comes to Syria. "The BDP is
only willing to go as far as the PKK is wiling to
let them."
In the absence of clear backing from a range of
regional players - including the Turkish government,
the PKK and the Syrian opposition - Syrian Kurds
opposed to the regime in Damascus have found a ready
ally in Massoud Barzani, the president of the
semiautonomous region of Iraqi Kurdistan. Unlike the
Shia-dominated government in Baghdad, which opposes
efforts to unseat Bashar, Barzani has openly backed
the transition to democratic rule in Syria.
In practical terms, he has extended his support to a
coalition of Kurdish political parties opposed to
the Assad regime. In January, Barzani invited
members
of the Kurdish opposition to Iraqi Kurdistan,
urging them to close ranks with other anti-regime
groups and to better prepare for a post-Assad
future. During a later visit to Washington, he
announced that Iraqi Kurds were ready to provide
their cousins across the border with "moral support,
political support, [and] financial support."
However, Barzani's backing may not be enough to
galvanise those Syrian Kurds who remain on the
sidelines of the year-old revolution against Assad -
or to sustain those who've already joined it.
According to Othman Ali, head of the Turkish-Kurdish
Studies Center in Erbil, it is now up to the Arab
opposition and its Turkish backers to win over the
Kurds. To try to do so is in Ankara's own interest.
"Unless Turkey speeds up its efforts to win the
hearts of Syrian Kurds by using its influence with
the SNC to encourage the council to be more
forthcoming with regard to Kurdish rights, as well
as ensure better representation for them in the SNC
and its executive Council, the PKK will avail itself
of the opportunity to [assert] itself," Ali wrote in
a recent commentary in Today's Zaman, a Turkish
daily. "The PKK could well take advantage of the
political and security vacuum which might be created
with the fall of Assad's regime to expand the areas
from which it can attack Turkey."
Of course, Ali cautions, to earn the Syrian Kurds'
trust Turkey must first come to terms with its own
Kurdish minority. A new national constitution, its
adoption expected later this year, may be the
Turkish government's last chance to do so.
Even if supporting the Syrian Kurds might appear be
a gamble for Turkey, it is one worth taking, says
Luqman Sulayman, a Kurdish writer and activist who
fled from Qamishli to Nusaybin last year. "Turkey
shouldn't fear the Kurds," he says. "In the next
government of Syria, the Kurds will be more
powerful. The Turks should want to have good
relations with us in the future."
Copyright © respective author or news agency,
thenational.ae
-
Syrian Kurdistan -
Related Links
-
In Syria, a Kurdish
wildcard no one wants to play 6.5.2012
-
The Obstacle to Syria
Regime Change? 3.5.2012
-
Syrian Kurds to
demand Russia to stop supporting Assad regime
2.5.2012
-
The Kurdish Issue and
Syria’s Democracy 25.4.2012
-
Syrian Geopolitics
25.4.2012
-
Kurds, Syria, and the
Chessboard 24.4.2012
-
No democracy in Syria
without just solution for Kurdish issue:
secretary of the Syrian Kurdish Left Party
20.4.2012
-
Syrian Kurdish
refugees find safety, but little comfort, in
Iraqi Kurdistan 20.4.2012
-
The Syrian National
Council is "proud of Syrian Kurds and their
flag": spokesman 19.4.2012
-
Syrian Kurds Remain
on the Sideline of the Uprising 18.4.2012
-
There is no such
thing as Syrian Kurdistan: Syrian opposition
Arab leader Burhan Ghalioun 17.4.2012
-
Syrian Kurds Unsure
on Uprisings and Turkey’s Role 16.4.2012
-
Syrian Kurds pose
problems for Turkey 16.4.2012
-
Syrian Opposition
Delegation Heads to Moscow 16.4.2012
-
Syrian Kurdish
National Council's opposition package will not
contain decentralization 14.4.2012
-
Changed Prospects for
Turkish Military Intervention in Syria 13.4.2012
-
Assad's Military
Gains and the Western-Sunni Setback in Syria
11.4.2012
-
Turkey preparing to
take "new steps" against Syria 11.4.2012
-
Turkey seeks consensus
for intervention in Syria 11.4.2012
-
Six Assad's soldiers
killed in Syrian Kurdistan 11.4.2012
-
Syria's Assad forces
arrest 20 Kurdish youth tried to cross into
Iraq's Kurdistan 9.4.2012
-
Syrian Arab
opposition fear Kurdish demands 9.4.2012
-
An appeal to the
international community - The legitimate rights
of Kurds in Syria must not be ignored 8.4.2012
-
Turkey trying to
prevent Kurds autonomy in Syria 8.4.2012
-
With a dose of
caution, Kurds oppose Syrian regime 6.4.2012
-
How Assad has come
between Kurds of Turkey and Syria 6.4.2012
-
Kurdish opposition
quits Syrian National Council 6.4.2012
-
Syrian Kurdish
National Council denies meeting PKK leader
6.4.2012
-
Syrian military kills
civilians in reprisals, 'executes own troops,'
defectors say 3.4.2012
-
Syrian Kurdish
National Council: We weren't invited to
participate in Friends of Syria conference
1.4.2012
-
Iraqi Kurdistan rejects
allegation of military training of Syrian Kurds
31.3.2012
-
Supporters of Syrian
opposition to meet in Turkey 31.3.2012
-
Arabs have less role to
play in Syria crisis than Iran and Turkey
31.3.2012
-
Syrian Kurds
‘receiving military training in Iraqi Kurdistan
for the day after Assad’ 30.3.2012
-
Kurds struggle for
recognition in Syrian revolt 30.3.2012
-
Syrian Kurds could
tip scales of Syrian conflict 30.3.2012
-
Syrian Kurdish
National Council reject PKK's warring words
30.3.2012
-
Iraq's Maliki does not
support arming Syrian opposition 30.3.2012
-
Iraq: Arab summit divided
over how to approach Syria 29.3.2012
-
RSF: Kurdish citizen
journalist kidnapped and murdered in Syria
29.3.2012
-
Kurds, Marginalized,
Could Be Key to Syrian Revolt’s Success
28.3.2012
-
Syrian Kurds: Time
to Assert Their Rights 28.3.2012
-
'Buffer zone along
Syrian border, national suicide for Turkey’:
Webster Griffin Tarpley 27.3.2012
-
...
Top |
Kurd Net
does not take credit for and is not responsible for the
content of news information on this page
|